A useful tipster record should help you understand what happened, what following the selections involved and which costs are excluded. A winning screenshot cannot answer those questions.
1. Look for a complete, dated history
Check when the record began and whether every advised selection appears, including losses, non-runners and corrections. The selection, market, advised odds and stake should be recorded before the event. A record reconstructed after results are known is not the same evidence.
BG Tips publishes service records linked from individual profiles. Publication makes a record inspectable; independent verification requires separate evidence of advance proofing and the organisation doing it. Do not assume the two terms mean the same thing.
2. Ask whether the prices were available
Advised-price results assume those prices could be taken. Compare when a selection was sent with when you could have acted. Shorter odds can materially change returns, especially over many bets. A BSP record uses a different price basis, which should be identified consistently.
For advertising claims, ASA/CAP’s tipster guidance discusses independent advance proofing and evidence of odds availability. A testimonial does not replace that evidence.
3. Compare like with like
Use the same completed period, staking basis and treatment of costs. An all-time profit from a seven-year record cannot be directly ranked against one year’s profit without considering exposure and time.
Our golf comparison, racing comparison and football comparison use the same twelve completed months where data is available. Read the table’s definition of drawdown: month-end measurements can miss larger losses within a month.
4. Separate strike rate, ROI and profit
Strike rate describes how often selections win. ROI compares profit with the total amount staked. Profit in points depends on the advised staking. A high strike rate alone does not establish profitability because the prices paid for winners also matter.
Bet count and the spread of results matter too. A short successful run, even at an impressive ROI, is limited evidence about future performance. No fixed proofing period can guarantee an enduring edge.
Why the staking basis matters
Consider three hypothetical bets at decimal odds of 2.10: two losses followed by a win. This illustrates the arithmetic; it is not a staking recommendation or a BG Tips performance claim.
| Measure | One point on each bet | One, two, then four points |
|---|---|---|
| Total staked | 3 points | 7 points |
| Profit after loss, loss, win | −0.90 points | +1.40 points |
| ROI (profit ÷ total staked) | −30% | +20% |
| Loss if all three bets lose | −3 points | −7 points |
The selections and prices are identical, but the stakes change both the return and the exposure. The larger third stake does not improve that bet’s chance of winning. A short successful sequence cannot establish a lasting advantage.
When stakes vary, compare the complete advised-stake record with a flat one-point record for the same selections. Look at total stakes and losses along the way, not only the final profit. These examples exclude subscription fees and exchange commission. Do not increase stakes to recover losses.
5. Include the subscription and other costs
Five points of betting profit at £5 per point is £25. After a £29 subscription, the result is a £4 loss. Use the fee actually paid for the period and account for exchange commission where applicable.
Calculate historical profit after fees. Increasing your stake to make a subscription look worthwhile also increases the money at risk; it is not a solution to an unsuitable service.
6. Check practical suitability
- When and how are selections delivered?
- How many bets are normally advised?
- Can you access the stated markets and understand their rules?
- What losses and drawdowns appear in the complete record?
- What is charged today and at renewal, and how do you cancel?
A suggested betting bank is not a cap on losses. Historical drawdowns can be exceeded, and a losing period need not recover. Only consider a service within a spending limit you can afford; choosing not to subscribe or bet is a valid outcome.
Choose on the record and the service
Explore the current tipster profiles and try the free pages. The free racing system and free golf sample have separate records and should not be used as proof for unrelated paid services.